Blog Post

Dr Cathy Wield - Physician health = physician mental health?

  • by Dr Cathy Wield
  • 12 May, 2019

DSN member, Dr Cathy Wield, successfully returned to work in emergency medicine in the UK after two bouts of major depression, which included hospital admissions and brain surgery.  Here Cathy reflects on how we are still reluctant to talk about physician mental health.

'Talking about physician health is talking about physician mental health, but we can’t quite bring ourselves to come out with that.  The question is why? 

I am the first to say that our mental health is totally linked to every other aspect of ourselves, that we are whole people – physical, mental & spiritual – by that not meaning religion but our sense of self within the world we live in.  But we still don’t really believe that mental and physical are inextricably linked or that to have a primarily mental condition is on a par with the physical. 

We hide this with our inability to talk about a diagnosed condition that is termed ‘psychiatric’. Of course this is nothing new and, for decades, we have hidden our distress in such ways that are acceptable to others. The term stress is more acceptable than di-stress!  But some of us have braved it and accepted a diagnosis such as depression, anxiety disorder or bipolar……but even amongst psychiatric illness there is a level of acceptability.  Few talk about addiction or personality disorder, let alone schizophrenia. 

But we are also in a vulnerable position because there is an increasing concern that physician health is all about what we can do to prevent ‘burnout’.   We are encouraged to exercise, do mindfulness have a healthy work:life balance etc.  The onus is on the individual to keep themselves healthy.  But if systemic stress and pressure continue unabated it misses the point completely and once again, stigma comes in through the back door.  It is an easy pathway to blame and that is something we need to avoid at all costs. 

I was invited to speak at the Emergency Medicine Continuing Education Forum (EMCEF) in Birmingham on May 8th 2019. I am lucky that I managed to survive severe depression and have been well for over a decade; being able to talk to colleagues in emergency medicine about my experience is a privilege that is not easy to come by.  I want to make this a subject that is interesting and compelling even for those who believe it’s ‘not their thing’ or they ‘don’t get it’.  Stigma is at the heart of it, because let’s face it, if we fail to recognise that there is no such thing as a purely ‘physical’ condition, then we cannot do our jobs well.  ‘So what about a fractured femur?’, some may say.  But our response to any physical insult involves emotion and pain is a brain event as much as sadness or anxiety! 

My talk: ‘what doesn’t kill us makes us stronger’ will, I hope, encourage emergency medicine doctors to seek support, without the worry of being alone or unusual for doing so. (Doctors' Support Network leaflets and information were available at the event. )'

Cathy  tweets about her experiences as doctor and patient, using the handle @cathywield1 and blogs here  She has written two books about her experiences: Life After Darkness: a doctor’s journey through severe depression 2006  and A Thorn In My Mind: mental illness, stigma and the church 2012

&me is our joint campaign, with the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons' Mind Matters Initiative, to encourage senior, currently well healthcare professionals including doctors, vets, dentists and pharmacists to informally self identify as having experienced a mental health condition in order to reduce the stigma of mental health in the healthcare professions.   Cathy is one of our amazing volunteers for this campaign.  Read her blog piece for the campaign here

Find out more about our campaign and how you might get involved here 
by Louise Freeman 23 Nov, 2020
Dr Louise Freeman addresses barriers to access to work faced by medics with mental ill health needing reasonable adjustments.
by Louise Freeman 09 Apr, 2020
Dr Louise Freeman is the co-chair of the Doctors' Support Network. Here, she talks about why prioritising your own health can feel difficult in times of crisis such as the coronavirus pandemic.
by Serena Haywood 10 Oct, 2019
Dr Serena Haywood on talking about her experience of mental ill health: 'The fear and isolation ... led me to take the risky decision to start talking about my mental health as much as I could to as many people as would listen.  I was advised not to but did it anyway.  And my life changed from there.'
by Caroline Elton 15 Aug, 2019
Psychologist Caroline Elton discusses the difficult issue of talking about our own mental ill health.  'I don’t want to collude with the fantasy that depression, or any other mental illness, only happens to other people. It has certainly happened to me. '
by Louise Freeman 14 Jun, 2019
CLANGERS, keeping well for medics, specialist support and creativity were all on the programme at our recent conference in Bristol.
by Dr Cathy Wield 05 Jun, 2019
Dr Cathy Wield discusses how and when to talk about our recovery from mental ill health.
by Louise Freeman & Angelika Luehrs 20 May, 2019
DSN co-chairs, Dr Louise Freeman and Dr Angelika Luehrs, discuss how and why we are talking about our own mental health as doctors, including an explanation of our AndMe anti stigma campaign with the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons' Mind Matters Initiative.
by Louise Freeman 08 May, 2019
BBC Radio Five Live discussion about Prof. Steve Robson's article recounting his experience of attempting suicide as a trainee doctor with comment from his colleague Dr Kate Tree and an interview with Dr Laura McGregor, consultant in emergency medicine
by Louise Freeman 24 Apr, 2019
Clare Gerada: ' We can't keep photographing the problem (physician health) - we need to do something about it.'
by Louise Freeman 17 Apr, 2019
Find out more about what YOU could get out of helping to run DSN!
Show More
Share by: