Blog Post

To disclose or not to disclose your own history of mental ill health as a healthcare practitioner - Caroline Elton 

  • by Caroline Elton
  • 15 Aug, 2019

Caroline Elton is an occupational psychologist specialising in supporting doctors and dentists.  Caroline has a best selling book about her experiences in this field - Also Human.  Here, she talks about the thorny question of disclosing one's own experience with mental ill health.

'I’m an occupational psychologist who specialises in supporting doctors. I’m also a woman who has experienced a number of periods of depression at different times in my life. I’ve taken anti-depressants, had psychiatric treatment, and benefitted hugely from a long period of psychotherapy. When a doctor comes to see me and talks about their depression, do I share my own psychiatric history? Probably not. 

‘But why not?’ you may ask – and that’s certainly a valid question. My reticence is partly due to my training, which discourages telling clients too much about one’s own personal stuff. And partly because people have come to talk to me about the difficulties they have been experiencing, and there’s always the danger that by adding in your own history, the focus can shift from them to you. 

But the fact that I typically refrain from talking to a client about my own experience of depression doesn’t mean that I have to remain silent. In my book ‘Also Human: the inner lives of doctors’ there’s a chapter which looks at the stigma doctors can face if it is known that they have suffered from a mental illness. When writing the chapter, it struck me as deeply hypocritical to, on the one hand, be arguing that there needed to be a culture of openness so that doctors could talk about their own mental health issues - and on the other hand, keeping shtum about my own experience of depression. It wasn’t exactly the bravest of self-disclosures, or the loudest, but if you read that chapter carefully, I mention that I too, like some of the doctors who come to see me, have had struggles with depression. 

Perhaps it’s a symptom of the stigma that still surrounds mental health issues in the medical profession – but in the hundreds of emails that I’ve received from doctors all over the world since my book was published – very few have commented on my self-disclosure. But Dr Louise Freeman – Co-Chair of DSN picked it up – and she asked me to write this brief piece. 

So #&Me. And whilst I don’t typically talk about it to the doctors who come to see me – I don’t want to collude with the fantasy that depression, or any other mental illness, only happens to other people. It has certainly happened to me. '


Buy Caroline's book 'Also Human' via the link here (a small percentage of the price will go to DSN without any extra cost to you)

&me is our joint campaign, with the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons' Mind Matters Initiative, to encourage senior, currently well healthcare professionals including doctors, vets, dentists and pharmacists to informally self identify as having experienced a mental health condition in order to reduce the stigma of mental health in the healthcare professions.   

Find out more about our campaign and how you might get involved here 
by Louise Freeman 23 Nov, 2020
Dr Louise Freeman addresses barriers to access to work faced by medics with mental ill health needing reasonable adjustments.
by Louise Freeman 09 Apr, 2020
Dr Louise Freeman is the co-chair of the Doctors' Support Network. Here, she talks about why prioritising your own health can feel difficult in times of crisis such as the coronavirus pandemic.
by Serena Haywood 10 Oct, 2019
Dr Serena Haywood on talking about her experience of mental ill health: 'The fear and isolation ... led me to take the risky decision to start talking about my mental health as much as I could to as many people as would listen.  I was advised not to but did it anyway.  And my life changed from there.'
by Louise Freeman 14 Jun, 2019
CLANGERS, keeping well for medics, specialist support and creativity were all on the programme at our recent conference in Bristol.
by Dr Cathy Wield 05 Jun, 2019
Dr Cathy Wield discusses how and when to talk about our recovery from mental ill health.
by Louise Freeman & Angelika Luehrs 20 May, 2019
DSN co-chairs, Dr Louise Freeman and Dr Angelika Luehrs, discuss how and why we are talking about our own mental health as doctors, including an explanation of our AndMe anti stigma campaign with the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons' Mind Matters Initiative.
by Dr Cathy Wield 12 May, 2019
Dr Cathy Wield discusses how we often shy away from naming physician mental health by using the term 'physician health'.
by Louise Freeman 08 May, 2019
BBC Radio Five Live discussion about Prof. Steve Robson's article recounting his experience of attempting suicide as a trainee doctor with comment from his colleague Dr Kate Tree and an interview with Dr Laura McGregor, consultant in emergency medicine
by Louise Freeman 24 Apr, 2019
Clare Gerada: ' We can't keep photographing the problem (physician health) - we need to do something about it.'
by Louise Freeman 17 Apr, 2019
Find out more about what YOU could get out of helping to run DSN!
Show More
Share by: